The Oregon Court of Appeals on November 12, 2026, upheld a $1,237,191.92 jury award in favour of Jim A. Atwood, his trust and J.A. Atwood Corporation against Lamar Obie Company, LLC.

The dispute concerned a west-facing brick wall on Atwood’s building on West Burnside Street in downtown Portland. The wall had carried commercial advertisements for decades. Atwood leased it to advertising companies, which sold the space and shared revenue with him.

The wall came under state sign rules after West Burnside Street became part of the National Highway System and was designated a state highway. Because the sign exceeded current size limits, it needed a special permit available for older signs that did not meet those limits.

A tenant, OnDisplay Advertising, applied for the permit in 2014 with Atwood’s written consent. Lamar Advertising subsequently bought OnDisplay’s assets, including the wall lease and rights to the application. When the state transportation department issued the permit in 2015, it initially named OnDisplay and later changed the permit to Lamar alone, without notifying Atwood.

In 2019, Atwood told Lamar he was ending the lease and asked it to transfer the permit to him. Lamar refused, removed the advertising equipment and obtained a relocation credit from the state. The transportation department later rejected Atwood’s application for a new permit because the wall exceeded the size limits. The appeals court upheld that administrative decision in June 2025.

In the civil case, Lamar challenged the jury’s award, including compensation for future lost advertising income. The company argued that Atwood’s expectations about the permit were not legally reasonable and that the future losses were speculative.

The appeals court rejected the arguments properly before it. The opinion, written by Presiding Judge Darleen Ortega, said a jury could reasonably find that the parties had a shared understanding that the leaseholder would not take away the permit needed for continued advertising. The court also found sufficient evidence for the jury to consider future losses and no errors in the jury instructions.