A US federal court has invalidated a Homeland Security Department plan to limit the stays of foreign students, researchers and journalists. The court described the proposed rule as arbitrary and unlawful. It had temporarily blocked the measure in September through a preliminary injunction.
The judge rejected the department’s reasoning that the restrictions were needed for national security and fraud prevention. The judge found that the stated justification was not plausible and that the costs of the limits were disproportionate to their benefits.
The ruling also found that the measure would hinder educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States, an activity the judge said Congress had intended to allow and encourage.
The department’s plan called for a maximum stay of four years for students and researchers. Journalists would have been limited to 240 days at a time. People in both groups could have applied for extensions without leaving the country.
A coalition of university unions, education organisations and journalists’ associations brought the case. The government has already challenged the preliminary injunction and can also appeal the latest ruling.
For years, the F visa category for students, the J category for exchange students and researchers, and the I category for journalists have allowed holders to remain for the duration of their status rather than for a fixed period. Students, for example, have been able to stay for the duration of their education.